Now 2023 Previous Articles Road Essays Road Reviews Author Black Authors Title Source Age Genre Series Format Inclusivity LGBTA Portfolio Artwork WIP

Recent posts

Month in review

Beast & Crown by Joel Ross
Beyond the Bright Sea by Lauren Wolk
Boundless by Jillian Tamaki
Carrying Albert Home by Homer Hickam
CatStronauts: Space Station Situation by Drew Brockington
Demon, Volume 4 by Jason Shiga
Feathertop by Robert D. San Souci
14 Hollow Road by Jenn Bishop
From Ant to Eagle by Alex Lyttle
The Great Shelby Holmes Meets Her Match by Elizabeth Eulberg
Hear the Wolves by Victoria Scott
Lights, Camera, Middle School! by Jennifer L. Holm
The Looney Experiment by Luke Reynolds
The Losers Club by Andrew Clements
The Lost Kingdom of Bamarre by Gail Carson Levine Lucky Broken Girl by Ruth Behar
Macy McMillan and the Rainbow Goddess by Shari Green
Murder on the Half Shelf by Lorna Barrett
One Last Word: Wisdom from the Harlem Renaissance by Nikki Grimes
One Mixed-Up Night by Catherine Newman
Ordinary Mishaps and Inevitable Catastrophes by Booki Vivat
Orphan Island by Laurel Snyder
Paper Girls Volume 3 by Brian K. Vaughan
Piecing Me Together by Renée Watson
Red Leech by Andrew Lane
Refugee by Alan Gratz
Ripped From the Pages by Kate Carlisle
The Scarebird by Sid Fleischman and Peter Sís
See You in the Cosmos by Jack Cheng
Walking with Miss Millie by Tamara Bundy
Wildlife Photographer of the Year: Portfolio 25 by Rosamund Kidman Cox

2017 books read and reviewed
Back Half round-up: Favorite books read and reviewed from July-December 2017 Canadian Books reviewed in 2017
Diverse Books Reviewed in 2017
First Book of the Year Graphic Novels Reviewed in 2017
It's Monday, What Are You Reading (December 04)
It's Monday, What Are You Reading (December 11)
It's Monday, What Are You Reading (December 18)
It's Monday, What Are You Reading (December 25)
Mysteries reviewed in 2017
Road Narrative Summary
November 2017 sources
November 2017 summary

Previous month

Rating System

5 stars: Completely enjoyable or compelling
4 stars: Good but flawed
3 stars: Average
2 stars: OK
1 star: Did not finish

Reading Challenges

Beat the Backlist 2023

Canadian Book Challenge: 2022-2023

Chicken Art

Privacy policy

This blog does not collect personal data. It doesn't set cookies. Email addresses are used to respond to comments or "contact us" messages and then deleted.

Ripped From the Pages: 12/20/17

Ripped From the Pages by Kate Carlisle

Ripped From the Pages by Kate Carlisle is the ninth Bibliophile Mystery. Guru Bob is expanding the compound's winery but adding a wine cave for tasting. In the process of boring through the wall, a secret room is exposed, packed full of treasures and containing a well dressed body.

Mostly this volume is a cold case with ties to WWII and to the Nazi confiscation of artwork. These were pieces squirreled out of Europe. They are also clues to Guru Bob's family history. Let's just say the story he's been telling his followers isn't true.

I personally wish this book had just been a cold case. But Brooklyn seems cursed to be in the middle of present day murders. Of course someone has to die and the person behind it is obvious from the very get-go — from the first introductions. Despite the obvious villain being obvious, we still have to wait until the final act for the present day crime.

Unfortunately the same ties to WWII reveal a flaw in the series — one that many mystery series suffer from — namely, the slippage of time. As I described in my review of Crunch Time by Diane Mott Davidson, the longer a series continues, the more obvious the inconsistencies between plot time and the temporal environment of the story (ie what sorts of things are available, references to current events, etc) become.

In Ripped From the Pages, it's stated that a little more than two years have passed since Brooklyn met her boyfriend. That happened in Homicide in Hardcover, the start of the series. That book was published in 2009. This volume was published in 2015 — six years later, not two years later. When thinking in terms of how many murder investigations Brooklyn has been part of, it's amazing she has had any time to do anything else as described in the books.

Then take a look at the body discovered in the secret room. He's been there roughly seventy years. That puts the time line for the mystery in 2014 — or when the book was being written. So which is it? Here, the difference really isn't that grand a thing — only a couple years, but as the series continues, this gap is likely to widen. What happens when it does, depends on how the author decides to handle it. Two extremes are: to rigidly insist it's still however many years back (as Sue Grafton does with her Alphabet Mystery books) or to just let the characters live in the present and have fun with the new technology (as Elizabeth Peters did in the Vicky Bliss mysteries).

The tenth book in the series is Books of a Feather (2016).

Three stars

Comments (0)

Lab puppy
Email (won't be posted):
Blog URL:

Twitter Tumblr Mastadon Flickr Facebook Facebook Contact me

1997-2023 Sarah Sammis